SAP JIT vs. JIC Inventory for Better Decision-Making

In wholesale distribution, inventory is both an asset and a liability. Too much stock ties up capital, while too little risks lost sales and disappointed customers. That’s why wholesalers are increasingly wrestling with two fundamental strategies: Just-in-Time (JIT) and Just-in-Case (JIC). Each approach has benefits and tradeoffs, and SAP’s suite of supply chain solutions can help wholesalers plan, implement, monitor, and optimize either strategy with precision. 

Dive deeper into JIT vs. JIC inventory below. 

COMPARING JIT VS. JIC INVENTORY 

Just-in-Time (JIT) is a lean approach that aims to minimize inventory holding. Stock arrives exactly when needed, reducing storage costs and waste. It’s especially appealing for high-value or perishable products where carrying inventory is expensive or risky.  

For instance, Nike reported that it cut lead times by 40% and increased productivity by 20% when it implemented JIT at its facilities in Southeast Asia. However, JIT depends heavily on a reliable supply chain. Any disruption, like supplier delays or sudden spikes in demand, can create stockouts and missed sales. 

Just-in-Case (JIC), in contrast, prioritizes availability. Wholesalers maintain higher safety stock to guard against uncertainty or unexpected demand surges. This approach reduces the risk of stockouts but increases holding costs, up to 20% to 30% of total inventory value, and can lead to waste if products don’t sell as forecasted.  

The decision between JIT vs. JIC often depends on market volatility, supplier reliability, product shelf life, and cash flow considerations. 

SAP SOLUTIONS SUPPORTING JIT AND JIC 

SAP provides tools that allow wholesalers to implement either inventory management strategy intelligently, or even combine elements of both: 

Forecasting and Demand Planning 

SAP Integrated Business Planning (IBP) enables wholesalers to model demand with high granularity. Accurate forecasts are the backbone of JIT: knowing exactly how much inventory will be needed, when, and where reduces the risk of both overstock and understock. For JIC, forecasts help determine optimal safety stock levels based on historical variability and service-level targets. 

Inventory Optimization 

SAP’s inventory optimization solutions calculate the right balance of stock across multiple locations. For JIT, they help plan replenishments to arrive in time, whereas for JIC, they can simulate “what if” scenarios to identify the minimal extra stock needed to maintain service levels without excessive carrying costs. 

Supply Chain Visibility and Collaboration 

One key to JIT success is visibility across the supply chain. SAP Supply Chain Control Tower provides real-time insights into supplier performance, shipment status, and inventory across all locations. For JIC, this tool allows wholesalers to monitor inventory health and adjust safety stock proactively. 

Automated Replenishment 

SAP Predictive Replenishment and Materials Management modules can automate ordering processes. In JIT environments, orders are triggered precisely when stock levels dip below thresholds. In JIC setups, replenishment can be scheduled to maintain desired buffer levels while minimizing manual intervention. 

WHEN TO USE JIT VS. JIC 

JIT is most effective in environments where supply chains are predictable and highly reliable. It’s particularly useful for high-value or fast-moving items where holding costs are significant or for perishable goods with a short shelf life.  

JIC, on the other hand, makes sense when demand is highly volatile or difficult to predict; suppliers are less reliable; lead times are long; or the cost of a stockout (lost sales or service-level penalties) is high. In these scenarios, maintaining a buffer of safety stock ensures continuity of supply. 

Many wholesalers today use a hybrid approach, combining JIT for high-turnover, predictable products, and JIC for slow-moving or critical items. SAP makes this feasible by allowing differentiated inventory policies at SKU, location, or customer level.  

FINAL THOUGHTS 

There’s no universal answer: choosing between JIT vs. JIC inventory is context-dependent. For wholesalers, the key is not just choosing one but understanding the tradeoffs of each and managing them with precision. SAP’s suite of solutions, from IBP and Predictive Replenishment to the Supply Chain Control Tower, provides the tools to implement either strategy confidently. 

By leveraging SAP, wholesalers can implement JIT and JIC strategies to ensure they are agile enough to respond to both predictable trends and unexpected disruptions. 

Click here to continue the conversation.