Comparing SAP Cloud ERP vs. SAP Cloud ERP Private
SAP Business Suite is a suite of solutions encompassing SAP’s entire cloud portfolio that runs on S/4HANA, SAP’s cloud-based ERP. Under SAP Business Suite, SAP offers two ERP options: SAP Cloud ERP and SAP Cloud ERP Private. SAP Cloud ERP refers to S/4HANA’s Public Cloud capabilities, while SAP Cloud ERP Private refers to S/4HANA’s Private Cloud capabilities. While both systems can run SAP’s solutions, there are advantages and disadvantages to each.
As businesses migrate to SAP for their ERP needs, they must decide between SAP Cloud ERP vs. SAP Cloud ERP Private. We compare the two for your consideration below.
SAP CLOUD ERP VS. SAP CLOUD ERP PRIVATE
Similarities
SAP Cloud ERP and SAP Cloud ERP Private are SAP’s cloud ERP systems that utilize SAP HANA, an in-memory database. Both provide a platform for SAP solutions to run on, the same user interface for customers, and integration capabilities with other, non-SAP software and systems. Both ERP systems also receive continuous upgrades and innovations from SAP.
Differences
Although SAP Cloud ERP and SAP Cloud ERP Private have the same general functions, there are many differences that set these two systems apart.
Customization and Control
One difference between these two systems is that SAP Cloud ERP Private often allows for more customizations, as organizations have more control over the infrastructure and updates for the system. SAP Cloud ERP Private enables more modifications and customizations for add-ons so that businesses can customize and configure individual SAP solutions to meet their specific needs. Meanwhile, SAP Cloud ERP offers customizations within a more limited scope. Users can apply in-app extensions and utilize third-party add-ons, but only to the extent of pre-defined extensions and configurations set by SAP, unlike SAP Cloud ERP Private, which allows for full flexibility.
This full flexibility is especially helpful for businesses in industries with strict regulatory compliance requirements. With SAP Cloud ERP Private, users can customize aspects of data collection and storage to meet specific regulations, which may not always be possible with SAP Cloud ERP’s limited customization options. Unlike SAP Cloud ERP, which stores data in a shared infrastructure with SAP, SAP Cloud ERP Private gives businesses full control over their data. This can be beneficial for businesses in the life sciences and finance industries, where data protection and privacy are extremely important.
SAP Cloud ERP Private also allows businesses to create their own innovation timeline, choosing when the system is updated, while SAP Cloud ERP receives major upgrades based on SAP’s fixed schedule. That said, users of SAP Cloud ERP can’t control when updates are administered and may experience disruptions in their business activity while the system updates.
Integration and Maintenance
While SAP Cloud ERP allows for less customization, it also means that, generally speaking, organizations aren’t required to do as much work to manage the system. Since SAP Cloud ERP is standardized, it comes ready-to-use, making the integration process much faster than it is with SAP Cloud ERP Private.
Maintenance for SAP Cloud ERP is also simpler and faster, with scheduled upgrades from SAP and quicker access to new features and innovations. On the other hand, with SAP Cloud ERP Private, organizations must manage maintenance in-house, meaning they are responsible for planning and managing upgrades to ensure they go smoothly.
Additionally, SAP Cloud ERP has many qualities that make it easier for employees to use than SAP Cloud ERP Private. Since SAP Cloud ERP comes ready-to-use, it is typically less complex, making it easier for new users to understand. This can make onboarding and integration faster and less expensive with SAP Cloud ERP when compared to SAP Cloud ERP Private.
Pricing and Costs
SAP Cloud ERP and SAP Cloud ERP Private also differ in their cost. While SAP product prices vary by business needs and size, SAP Cloud ERP typically has lower initial costs than SAP Cloud ERP Private. The implementation and integration of these systems include multiple costs that businesses must consider.
For example, since SAP Cloud ERP Private allows for extensive customization, businesses have to maintain and integrate it on their own accord. This requires businesses utilizing SAP Cloud ERP Private to have skilled in-house IT teams and third-party consultants to maintain the system, while also setting aside time for development and testing of customizations, all of which raise expenses.
From resources to time constraints, SAP Cloud ERP typically costs businesses less than SAP Cloud ERP Private, and businesses looking to migrate to a cloud ERP must consider how these costs will fit into their company’s budget.
FINDING THE RIGHT FIT FOR YOUR BUSINESS
SAP Cloud ERP and SAP Cloud ERP Private each have their benefits and downsides that are important for companies to consider before deciding on which cloud ERP is right for them. SAP Cloud ERP is typically better for small- to mid-sized organizations looking for a quick implementation with standardized functionality, while SAP Cloud ERP Private is often a better fit for larger organizations that may want or need more flexibility and control.
Above all, businesses must carefully consider their budget and business needs when deciding which ERP system to implement.
If your organization needs help deciding between SAP Cloud ERP vs. SAP Cloud ERP Private, contact us today.
Contributions from Natalie Pollock